Apple is set to face a landmark trial in Paris in June 2025 over allegations that it deliberately limited the repairability of its iPhones, a case that could result in fines amounting to billions of euros. The charges, brought by French prosecutors, mark the first time the tech giant has been prosecuted in France for so-called planned obsolescence.
The case was initiated by the campaign group Stop Planned Obsolescence (HOP), which filed a complaint in December 2022. The group welcomed the decision to bring the case to court, calling it a significant step for consumer rights and environmental protection. Apple, however, has strongly denied the allegations, stating, "We strongly contest these unfounded allegations."
Planned obsolescence refers to practices where manufacturers intentionally shorten the lifespan of a product to encourage consumers to buy newer models. In this case, Apple is accused of configuring its software to make it difficult or impossible for independent repair shops to fix iPhones, thereby pushing customers toward official Apple service centers or new purchases.
Charges and potential penalties
If found guilty, Apple could face a fine of up to €300,000, plus an additional penalty of up to 5% of its annual global revenue. Based on Apple's latest financial figures, that could amount to roughly €21.7 billion. The company might also be liable for compensation claims from consumers.
The trial, scheduled to begin on June 17, 2025, will last four days. Apple Distribution International and its parent company, Apple Inc., are both named as defendants. The charges relate to a period from November 2021 to July 2024, during which Apple is alleged to have obstructed repairs on a range of iPhone models, including the iPhone XS, iPhone 12, 13, 14, and 15 series, as well as the 2022 iPhone SE.
Specific examples cited in the case include the disabling of Face ID if a camera is replaced by an unauthorized repair shop, and the "battery health" feature ceasing to function after third-party repairs. These practices, according to the prosecution, were designed to boost sales of Apple's flagship product, which accounts for roughly half of the company's annual revenue of over $400 billion.
This is not the first time Apple has faced legal action in France over its repair policies. In 2021, the company agreed to pay €25 million to settle a case related to software updates that slowed down older iPhone models without informing users. That settlement, however, did not include an admission of guilt.
The upcoming trial is being closely watched across Europe, as it could set a precedent for how tech companies handle repairability and consumer rights. France has been at the forefront of the "right to repair" movement, and this case aligns with broader EU efforts to make electronics more sustainable and reduce electronic waste.
For European consumers, the outcome may influence how easily they can repair their devices and how long they can expect their gadgets to last. It also raises questions about the balance between innovation and planned obsolescence in the tech industry.
As the trial approaches, both Apple and its critics are preparing for a legal battle that could reshape the landscape of consumer electronics in Europe. The case underscores the growing scrutiny on big tech companies and their environmental and ethical responsibilities.


