European governments are entitled to tighten their migration policies, but they must not let those efforts erode their human rights commitments, Council of Europe Secretary General Alain Berset has warned. In an interview with Euronews, the former Swiss president pushed back against the notion that Europe is facing a migration crisis or that the right to asylum has become politically unsustainable.
“Human rights are human rights for everybody or for no one,” Berset said, underscoring the Council of Europe’s role as the continent’s guardian of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Berset acknowledged that governments have legitimate concerns about irregular arrivals and that the European legal framework does not prevent deportations of individuals who have no legal right to stay. He pointed to rulings by the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, which have upheld some expulsions while striking down others, as evidence that the system can accommodate enforcement while protecting fundamental rights.
His comments come as five EU member states — Denmark, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, and Lithuania — announced a partnership with Rwanda to establish a so-called return hub for rejected asylum seekers. The plan, unveiled on Monday, is part of a broader push by some European capitals to process and deport migrants outside the bloc’s borders.
Berset expressed regret that the initiative appeared to have been developed without continuing earlier discussions initiated at the Council of Europe. He questioned whether such external return hubs are compatible with European human rights standards, noting that the organisation’s legal framework requires careful scrutiny of any arrangement that outsources asylum procedures.
Rules-based order at stake
The Secretary General stressed that respect for the rules-based international order is essential for stability, peace, and predictability across the continent. He argued that this principle must also underpin Europe’s approach to migration, even as political pressure mounts to show decisive action.
“If we start making exceptions for certain groups or certain policies, we undermine the very foundation that protects all of us,” Berset said, adding that the Council of Europe stands ready to assess any new measures against its legal standards.
The Rwanda plan has drawn criticism from human rights groups and some legal experts, who argue that transferring asylum seekers to a third country with limited safeguards could violate the principle of non-refoulement — the prohibition on returning people to places where they face persecution. The European Court of Human Rights has previously blocked similar transfers, including a 2020 ruling that stopped the UK from sending asylum seekers to Rwanda.
Berset’s remarks reflect a growing tension between EU member states seeking to deter irregular migration and the continent’s legal obligations. While the European Commission has proposed a new pact on migration and asylum, individual countries have increasingly pursued bilateral deals with third countries, such as the recent agreement between Italy and Albania.
The Council of Europe, which includes 46 member states beyond the EU, has repeatedly called for a balanced approach that combines border management with respect for human dignity. Berset’s intervention is likely to fuel debate ahead of the next EU summit, where migration is expected to be a key agenda item.
As European leaders weigh tougher measures, the Secretary General’s warning serves as a reminder that the continent’s credibility depends on upholding the values it claims to defend. “We can manage migration effectively without sacrificing our principles,” he said. “The two are not mutually exclusive.”


