Politics Business Culture Technology Environment Travel World
Home› Culture› Feature
Culture · Exclusive

HBO's Harry Potter reboot faces online backlash over new clip

HBO's Harry Potter reboot faces online backlash over new clip
Culture · 2026
Photo · Tomas Horak for European Pulse
By Tomas Horak Culture & Lifestyle Nov 16, 2026 3 min read

HBO's upcoming Harry Potter television series has once again found itself at the center of online scorn. A newly released clip, intended to build anticipation, has instead triggered a wave of criticism across social media platforms, with many fans questioning the very existence of the reboot.

The scene depicts the Hogwarts students assembled in the Great Hall as John Lithgow's Albus Dumbledore makes his grand entrance. But rather than inspiring excitement, the footage has been met with a chorus of disapproval, with viewers describing it as "lifeless," "cold," and "absolute slop that should not exist."

One user on X (formerly Twitter) wrote: "As a millennial who spent hours upon hours reading Harry Potter growing up, I'm insulted by this." Another compared the production unfavorably to the budget retailer Temu, quipping: "It's actually so funny they spent millions of dollars to make Temu Harry Potter."

The backlash is not new. When the first trailer dropped in March, fans already criticized the lack of magical atmosphere. This latest clip appears to have reinforced those concerns, with one commenter noting: "It looks very cold. I like the organic warmth of the original's grading."

Others have drawn parallels to Amazon's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, which also faced intense fan scrutiny. "This is going to be the HP version of 'Rings of Power'," one user predicted. Another remarked: "There is a profound sense of 'why are we doing this' that permeates every frame."

A series mired in controversy

The reboot has been controversial from the outset. Many fans have questioned the need for a new adaptation of J.K. Rowling's beloved books, especially given the success of the original film series. Others have expressed reluctance to watch the show due to Rowling's public statements on transgender issues, which have been widely criticized as transphobic.

The new series, which is set to run for a decade across multiple seasons, aims to offer a more faithful adaptation of the books than the films could. However, the early footage has done little to convince skeptics. One viewer commented: "The best way to describe the new Harry Potter series is that they all look like they're fully aware that they're in a Harry Potter series."

Another critic remarked: "Why's it filmed like an SNL skit?" – a reference to the sketch comedy show's often flat, stage-like production values.

Despite the negative buzz, HBO remains committed to the project, which is expected to be a cornerstone of its streaming strategy. The series is being produced in the UK, with a cast that includes Lithgow as Dumbledore and a host of young actors in the iconic student roles.

For fans of the wizarding world, the debate over the reboot is part of a broader conversation about nostalgia and adaptation in the streaming era. As one user put it, with a touch of irony: "Absolute cinema."

The reaction also highlights the challenges facing studios as they mine beloved franchises for new content. While some reboots have succeeded in winning over audiences, others have faced fierce resistance. The Harry Potter series will need to overcome significant skepticism if it hopes to cast a spell on viewers when it premieres.

For those planning a trip to the UK to visit filming locations, five UK rail journeys for Harry Potter fans offer a nostalgic alternative to the new series.

As the online discourse continues, one thing is clear: the new Harry Potter series has a long way to go to win over its most devoted fans.

More from this story

Next article · Don't miss

Serbian MiG-29 crash near Belgrade kills veteran pilot

A Serbian MiG-29 crashed near Belgrade on Tuesday, killing pilot Major Goran Bulajić. The defence ministry has launched an investigation into the cause of the crash.

Read the story →
Serbian MiG-29 crash near Belgrade kills veteran pilot