European Union member states have taken a significant step toward introducing a 10-year probation period for new members, a mechanism designed to prevent future entrants from undermining the bloc's core values. The proposal, which would apply first to Montenegro, includes the possibility of suspending a newcomer's voting rights if it commits serious rule-of-law violations or obstructs EU decision-making.
The European Commission initially floated a 15-year probation, but several countries—notably Italy and other members of the Friends of the Western Balkans group, which advocates for the region's swift accession—argued that such a long period could hardly be considered temporary. Ireland, which holds the rotating EU Council presidency and chairs talks among member states, proposed shortening the period to 10 years, with a possible five-year extension. According to an EU diplomat with direct knowledge of the discussions, the proposal received broad support from EU ambassadors on Wednesday.
Ambassadors showed far greater willingness to compromise than the officials who had spent weeks negotiating the details, the diplomat said. The more contentious issue is what would trigger a suspension of voting rights. Montenegro, the country closest to joining the bloc, has warned that any decision must be based on objective criteria and systematic breaches of EU values and rules.
Disputes over 'sincere cooperation'
Several member states sympathetic to candidate countries object to including breaches of “sincere cooperation”—the EU treaty principle requiring members to work together in good faith and refrain from jeopardising the bloc's objectives—as a trigger. They argue that such breaches are difficult to assess objectively. These countries also oppose suspending new members' voting rights altogether, fearing the mechanism could be used to force newcomers to abandon positions close to their national interest, creating a de facto second tier of EU members.
Ireland also proposed changing how the safeguard is triggered, with decisions taken by qualified majority—meaning a majority of countries representing at least 65% of the EU's population. Here, too, member states did not object strongly.
The discussions now shift from general rules for future members to how they would apply to Montenegro. Ireland's proposal will form the basis of the safeguards in Montenegro's accession treaty, which the Commission aims to have signed by June 2027. Officials are expected to hold their first technical discussions on a draft of the relevant section of the treaty, Chapter 35, early next week. Podgorica, which cannot negotiate this part of the treaty, has been lobbying member states in the meantime.
Montenegro has set an ambitious target of joining the EU by 2028, a goal its envoy has called “very realistic.” The country insists on full membership, not a partial or transitional status. The new probation mechanism, however, could mean that even after accession, Montenegro would remain under special scrutiny for a decade.
The move comes as the EU seeks to avoid a repeat of the experience with Hungary under Viktor Orbán, whose government violated the bloc's basic values and repeatedly wielded its veto to block decisions requiring unanimity. The new mechanism is designed to give the EU more leverage over future members, but critics warn it could create a two-tier system and undermine the principle of equality among member states.
As the EU expands its focus to the Western Balkans, the success of this probation model will be closely watched. For now, the broad support among ambassadors signals a pragmatic compromise, but the details remain to be negotiated. The coming weeks will be crucial as officials begin drafting the specific provisions for Montenegro's accession treaty.


